Swiss Women's Hockey Is Between Skepticism and Optimism
- 6 min read

Swiss Women's Hockey Is Between Skepticism and Optimism

Swiss Women's Hockey Is Between Skepticism and Optimism by Nicole Haase

Switzerland won their only game of the tournament on Saturday, defeating Germany 3-2 in overtime on a goal from Alina Müller. The win ensures that Switzerland stays in Group A in the top division alongside USA, Canada, Finland and Czechia.

It would be difficult to overstate how frustrated, dejected and at their wits' end Switzerland appeared to be after losing the bronze medal game at the 2023 IIHF Women's World Championships in Brampton. Coach Colin Muller was stumped for words in how to describe how far behind Czechia he felt his team was. It was Switzerland's sloppiest game and their lack of depth showed. Lara Stalder and Alina Müller tried to do it all themselves, but could not.

In the mixed zone, Müller wondered if there was something she should have done different or something more she could have given. Stalder, the captain, was more soft-spoken than normal and seemed like she was still processing that her team had lost when she felt so sure they would win. There was a hopelessness to all of them and coach Muller in particular seemed to be struggling not to lose his composure out of frustration for all the things his team could not seem to do in the game.

So it was an interesting contrast in demeanor on Thursday when Switzerland lost to Finland 3-1 in the 2024 tournament quarterfinals. Despite not having won a game all tournament, Switzerland has been much more competitive. Finland’s goals came on unusual bounces and fluky plays and the Swiss just missed equalizing the game a few times. The loss, they felt, was more about how sometimes the pucks don't bounce your way. They weren't outplayed. They weren't missing easy passes and plays. They just as easily could have won as they lost and that made all the difference for Stalder, who felt like it showed steps forward for Switzerland.

She was in similar good spirits after Saturday's win. She started her postgame press availability by releasing a deep breath with a smile. If nothing else, her team won their final game. They were resilient and bounced back after Germany tied the game twice. With a young team, there were so many lessons to be learned that can help them in the future.

Müller wasn’t quite so bullish. Yes, there are good young players on this team, she said, but the lack of true professional options for Swiss players means most stop playing by the time they are 25 years old. She is the lone Swiss national in the PWHL. Most of her Switzerland teammates play in Switzerland, where hockey is like a part time job. Until the sport can support women as 100% professionals, women will be forced to find other employment and often move on from the sport before they are ready to be finished playing. (Sound familiar?)

"I think we have more young talented players, but still our older ones stop too early so we can't really build that core. The next step is we don’t have to work 100% next to hockey so once you turn 25 you can still play hockey and you don't have to stop. Definitely promising with the young stars in the game, but we have to keep them in the game longer than just 25," said Müller.

Coach Muller wasn't beside himself like he was in 2023. His team played cleaner and didn't look like they'd never learned how to pass, but he still doesn't have the depth he needs to run three or four lines for the length of a game. Their top unit averaged more than 26 minutes of ice time led by Lara Christen on defense with 30:14 minutes and Müller on offense with 29:12 minutes. Together the top five were on ice more than twice as long as the third line. Just three players on the Swiss fourth line saw the ice in the relegation game, for a total of nine minutes.

"We have not enough players to choose from. There's not many other ones sitting around. We have three or four regulars that couldn’t make it this year and that's what happens. If three or four miss, it's a struggle. We've had a few retire. You just can't replace them. A big compliment on our younger players, they played really well. But to compete at a top level over two weeks you need depth, you need strength and at the moment we just don’t have that," said Muller.

"I think we had a younger team this year and it was a struggle for us the whole tournament. I don't know if we have enough players to play at this caliber. We had to shorten our bench a fair amount all the time."

Prior to the 2023 tournament, Stalder announced that she was leaving the SDHL in Sweden, where she'd played for six years following college at Minnesota Duluth. After the tournament, it was announced that Stalder would be joining EV Zug, who would be restarting the women's program. They had a women's team from 1990-2007. Now, Stalder is in a hybrid position, both in the front office and on the ice with an eye towards girls' hockey development. EV Zug started in the B Division and earned promotion in their first year.

"A lot has happened in a year. We wanted to create a movement on a regional basis. Teams and companies are investing in women's hockey just the way they invest in men's hockey. We get a great facility, great practice times. We have a really young team. We took on girls that we see they want to develop. They have a couple years to develop, and the future's bright now we moved on to the first league," said Stalder.

She hopes what EV Zug is doing serves as a blueprint for what can happen at other clubs and that stakeholders at all levels start putting pressure on clubs to support their women's and girls' teams. Stalder said she doesn't regret opting to go home to Switzerland as opposed to playing in the PWHL. She signed a three year contract and at that point, she'll be 32. She doesn’t know what her future playing career looks like, but filling in the gaps of growing the game and development are important to her.

"I see myself as part of a project right now working to grow the game at home. I want to be part of something bigger. That's why I chose to go home and create this movement. I want to have little girls play in my hometown region. Moving forward year by year, more girls play, more structures, more professional structures and that's the way forward," said Stalder.

There is a gap between Stalder's optimism and others' frustrations. Stalder is looking at the long view for girls and women's hockey in Switzerland, but Muller and Müller are commenting on the reality of trying to be competitive at the international level right now.

One of the Swiss standouts of the 2024 IIHF U18 Women’s World Championships in Zug this January was Ivana Wey. She earned a spot on this senior team and is one of Stalder's teammates at EV Zug. Getting to play regularly helped in a better environment elevated her game and made her ready to be on this team in a way she wasn't a year ago.

More enrollment is a big goal of Stalder's, but men's clubs also could invest in and support women's teams to accelerate the development of younger players and help build up a pool of talent for the senior team. It shouldn't be on a player to be facilitating development while filling the gaps that her country's Federation are happy to leave for girls and women in hockey. Stalder doesn't think she has all the answers. She's doing what feels right to try and make the path to women's hockey success for Swiss girls looks different than it did for her.

Muller doesn't know what the solution is. But he's not actually sure having won this game and his team staying in Group A is a good thing. It felt like there was a ton of subtext in his postgame comments – like what wasn't being said was as important as what was. The Swiss women's national has had a rough couple of seasons, but it feels like nothing has changed. There's no more support or funding. Players are still retiring and moving on from hockey. The Swiss women's team feels like it's in limbo.

"I think we have a lot of work in front of us," he said. "Whether it’s good to play in the top group next year or the second group I'm really not quite sure anymore."